Carpet Store in Shelter Island

Premium Flooring That Actually Lasts

Expert installation, luxury materials, and the Beautiful Guarantee that protects your investment in your Shelter Island home.

Hear from Our Customers

Luxury Carpet Store Shelter Island

Floors That Match Your Standards

Walk into rooms that feel completely transformed. Your carpet becomes the foundation that ties everything together—soft underfoot, warm in winter, and quiet enough that you actually notice the difference. No more cold mornings on hard surfaces. No more echoing footsteps disrupting your peace. Just beautiful, professionally installed carpet that makes your house feel like the sanctuary you’ve always wanted. The difference isn’t just comfort. It’s the confidence that comes with knowing your floors were installed right the first time, backed by our Beautiful Guarantee and nearly four decades of experience serving discerning Shelter Island homeowners.

Flooring Store Shelter Island NY

Island Living Requires Real Expertise

We’ve been serving Shelter Island and the greater Hamptons area since 1988. We understand what coastal living does to flooring—the salt air, the humidity, the sand that gets tracked in from beautiful beaches. More importantly, we understand Shelter Island homeowners. You’ve invested significantly in your property, and you expect flooring solutions that enhance that investment, not compromise it. Local architects trust us for their most important projects because we deliver results that last. When you’re dealing with ferry schedules and the unique challenges of island living, you need a flooring company that gets it right the first time.

Carpet Installation Shelter Island NY

Simple Process, Professional Results

We start with a free in-home consultation where we bring samples directly to you. No need to make multiple ferry trips—we understand your time is valuable. During the consultation, we assess your space, discuss your lifestyle needs, and show you options from our extensive selection. We use our digital room visualizer so you can see exactly how different carpets will look in your actual rooms. Once you choose your carpet, we handle everything from ordering to installation. Our professional installers arrive on schedule, protect your furniture and belongings, and use dustless equipment to keep your home clean throughout the process. After installation, we walk through everything with you to ensure it meets both our standards and yours.

Ready to get started?

Explore More Services

About Hamptons Carpet One

Get a Free Consultation

Flooring and Carpet Store Shelter Island

Everything You Need, Nothing You Don't

Our carpet installation service includes one of the largest selections on Long Island, featuring carpets from major manufacturers with five different warranty levels to fit any budget. Shelter Island homeowners particularly appreciate our stain-resistant options that handle the reality of coastal living—beach sand, pet accidents, wine spills, and everything else island life throws at your floors. We also create custom area rugs and install stair runners that complement your new carpet perfectly. For older Shelter Island homes, we provide solutions for uneven subfloors and structural challenges that other contractors often overlook. Our dustless refinishing service means you can upgrade existing hardwood areas without the mess, creating a cohesive flooring plan throughout your home. Every installation comes with our Beautiful Guarantee—if you don’t love your floors, we’ll replace them for free.

How long does carpet installation take in Shelter Island homes?

Most residential carpet installations in Shelter Island take one to two days, depending on the size of your project and any prep work needed. We’ll give you an exact timeline during your in-home consultation. For a typical living room and dining room, expect one full day. Whole-house projects usually take two days, sometimes three if we’re also handling stairs or custom work. We protect your furniture and belongings throughout the process, so you can stay in your home comfortably while we work.

Can you install carpet over existing hardwood floors?

Yes, we can install carpet over existing hardwood floors, and it’s actually quite common in Shelter Island homes. We use a pad system that protects the hardwood underneath, so you can return to wood floors later if desired. This approach works well when hardwood floors are in poor condition but you’re not ready for the expense of refinishing. The carpet installation provides immediate comfort and warmth while preserving your future options. We’ll assess your existing hardwood during the consultation to ensure it’s structurally sound for carpet installation.

What carpet options work best for Shelter Island's coastal environment?

Shelter Island’s coastal conditions require carpet that can handle humidity, salt air, and sand tracked in from the beach. We recommend solution-dyed nylon or triexta fibers with built-in stain resistance—these materials resist moisture, maintain their color, and clean easily. For high-traffic areas like entryways and family rooms, we often suggest loop pile or cut-and-loop styles that hide dirt and wear better than plush carpets. These styles work especially well with our stain-resistant treatments that handle everything from wet bathing suits to sandy feet.

Do you offer dustless refinishing for hardwood floors?

Absolutely. Our state-of-the-art dustless sanding and refinishing equipment captures 99% of dust during the process, making it perfect for occupied Shelter Island homes. This technology allows us to refinish your hardwood floors without the mess and disruption of traditional sanding. The dustless process is particularly valuable in Shelter Island homes where you want to avoid dust settling on furniture, artwork, or other valuable belongings. We can refinish your floors while you continue living in your home, and you’ll be amazed at how clean the process is compared to conventional methods.

What's included with your Beautiful Guarantee?

Our Beautiful Guarantee is simple: if you don’t love your floors, we’ll replace them for free. This guarantee covers both materials and installation, giving you complete peace of mind with your flooring investment. The guarantee reflects our confidence in both our products and our installation quality. We’ve been serving Shelter Island and the Hamptons since 1988, and we stand behind every job we do. If there’s any issue with your carpet—whether it’s appearance, performance, or installation quality—we make it right at no cost to you.

How do I schedule a consultation for my Shelter Island home?

Scheduling a consultation is easy—just call us or request an appointment online. We bring samples directly to your Shelter Island home, so you can see how different carpets look in your actual lighting and with your existing décor. During the consultation, we’ll measure your space, discuss your lifestyle needs, and show you options that fit your budget and style preferences. We use our digital room visualizer to help you see exactly how different carpets will look in your rooms. The consultation is completely free, with no obligation to purchase.

Local Resources

Shelter Island, NY is located in Suffolk County in New York State

Other Services we provide in Shelter Island