Hear from Our Customers
Your hardwood floors become the foundation that ties every room together. When you walk into a home with quality hardwood, you immediately feel the warmth and character that only real wood can provide.
The right hardwood flooring doesn’t just look beautiful—it adds measurable value to your property. Real estate professionals consistently report that homes with hardwood floors sell faster and command higher prices. In Shelter Island’s unique market, where quality matters and homes are investments for generations, this difference becomes even more significant.
You’ll enjoy floors that stand up to island life while maintaining their beauty for decades. Unlike carpet that traps salt air and moisture or vinyl that shows wear patterns, properly installed hardwood actually improves with age when maintained correctly.
We’ve been serving Shelter Island families from our Southampton showroom for over a decade. We understand the unique character of island homes—from historic cottages to modern waterfront properties—and the quality standards that Shelter Island homeowners expect.
We know that choosing flooring for your home isn’t just about picking a product. It’s about finding the right solution for your lifestyle, your budget, and your vision. We take time to understand what you’re trying to accomplish before we make any recommendations.
The Beautiful Guarantee® backs every installation we complete. If you’re not completely satisfied with your new floors, we’ll replace them at no cost to you. That’s the kind of confidence you get when you work with a hardwood flooring contractor that’s built its reputation on delivering results that last.
We start with a free consultation at your Shelter Island home where we assess your space, discuss your preferences, and provide honest recommendations based on your specific needs. We measure everything precisely and explain your options without any pressure. Most customers get their detailed quote within 48 hours.
Once you’ve selected your flooring, we handle all the preparation work. This includes protecting your furniture and belongings, preparing the subfloor, and ensuring proper moisture barriers are in place—especially important in Shelter Island’s coastal environment.
Installation day runs smoothly because we’ve planned every detail in advance. Our certified hardwood flooring contractor team works efficiently while maintaining the highest quality standards. We clean up completely each day and conduct a final walkthrough to ensure everything meets both our standards and yours.
You’ll receive care instructions specific to coastal conditions and our commitment to address any concerns that arise. Most customers are surprised by how seamless the entire process feels from start to finish.
Ready to get started?
We carry solid hardwood, engineered hardwood, and luxury vinyl options to match every budget and application. Popular species include oak, maple, hickory, and exotic woods, available in various widths and finishes. Current trends favor lighter, natural tones and wider planks that showcase the wood’s natural grain patterns—perfect for Shelter Island’s relaxed coastal aesthetic.
Shelter Island’s coastal environment requires careful consideration of moisture and seasonal changes. We understand these local conditions and recommend appropriate products and installation methods for long-term performance. We also specialize in hardwood floor refinishing for existing floors, often transforming tired surfaces into stunning focal points.
Many Shelter Island homeowners are surprised to learn that refinishing can be more cost-effective than replacement. Our refinishing process can handle everything from minor scratches to complete color changes, giving your floors a fresh new look.
Our digital room visualizer lets you see how different options will look in your actual space before making final decisions. This technology, combined with our sample program and free design consultations, ensures you’re completely confident in your choice.
Hardwood flooring costs in the Shelter Island area typically range from $8 to $15 per square foot installed, depending on the species, grade, and complexity of your project. Solid hardwood generally costs more than engineered options, but both provide excellent long-term value that’s particularly important in Shelter Island’s premium real estate market.
Several factors affect your total investment: the type of wood you choose, the condition of your existing subfloor, any custom work needed, and the total square footage. We provide detailed written estimates that break down all costs so you understand exactly what you’re paying for.
Most Shelter Island homeowners find that quality hardwood flooring pays for itself through increased home value and reduced long-term maintenance compared to other flooring types. We offer financing options to help make your project more manageable, and we work with your budget to find the best solution.
Engineered hardwood often performs best in Shelter Island’s coastal environment because it’s more stable in changing humidity conditions than solid wood. The multiple-layer construction resists expansion and contraction that can cause problems with solid hardwood near water—a real consideration for island homes.
For solid hardwood installations, we recommend species like white oak or hickory that naturally handle moisture changes better than softer woods. Proper acclimation before installation and appropriate moisture barriers are essential regardless of which option you choose.
We also discuss finish options that provide extra protection against humidity and salt air. We have extensive experience with coastal installations and know which products and techniques deliver the best long-term performance in your specific island environment.
Most existing hardwood floors can be refinished rather than replaced, often saving you significant money while achieving beautiful results. Our hardwood floor refinishing process evaluates your current floors to determine if refinishing is viable based on the wood thickness, condition, and any previous refinishing work.
The refinishing process involves sanding away the old finish and any surface damage, then applying new stain and protective topcoats. This typically takes 3-5 days depending on the size of your project and drying conditions. Many Shelter Island homes have solid hardwood floors that are perfect candidates for refinishing.
Hardwood floor refinishing works particularly well for floors that have years of wear, scratches, or outdated stain colors. The results often look as good as new flooring at a fraction of the cost. We’ll be honest about whether refinishing or replacement makes more sense for your specific situation.
Most hardwood flooring installations in Shelter Island homes take 3-7 days, depending on the size of the project and the type of flooring chosen. Solid hardwood typically requires more time than engineered products because of acclimation requirements—especially important in our coastal climate.
We schedule installations to minimize disruption to your daily routine. Smaller projects like single rooms often complete in 1-2 days, while whole-house installations may take a full week. Ferry schedules and weather conditions can occasionally affect timing, but we plan around these island realities.
We provide realistic timelines upfront and keep you informed of progress throughout the project. We understand that having work done in your home is disruptive, so we work efficiently while maintaining our quality standards.
Yes, all our hardwood flooring installations come with comprehensive warranties covering both materials and workmanship. Manufacturer warranties typically cover defects in the wood itself, while our installation warranty protects against issues with the actual installation work.
The Beautiful Guarantee® goes beyond standard warranties by promising complete satisfaction with your finished floors. If you’re not happy with the results, we’ll replace your flooring at no additional cost to you. This level of protection is especially valuable for Shelter Island homeowners making significant investments in their properties.
We also provide detailed care instructions specific to coastal conditions and remain available to address any questions or concerns that arise after installation. Most issues, if they occur, become apparent within the first few months, and we respond quickly to resolve any problems.
Hardwood floors in Shelter Island require minimal daily maintenance—regular sweeping or dry mopping removes dirt and debris that can scratch the surface. Occasional damp mopping with appropriate hardwood cleaners keeps floors looking their best without damage from harsh chemicals.
The coastal environment means paying attention to humidity levels, especially during seasonal changes. Using area rugs in high-traffic zones and maintaining consistent indoor humidity helps prevent premature wear and seasonal movement that’s more common in island homes.
Most hardwood floors benefit from professional deep cleaning and recoating every 3-5 years, depending on traffic and wear patterns. This maintenance extends the life of your floors significantly and keeps them looking like new. We provide specific care recommendations based on your flooring choice and Shelter Island’s unique coastal conditions.
Local Resources
Other Services we provide in Shelter Island
